«LIAN SHANBO AND ZHU YINTAI» («THE BUTTERFLY LOVERS») VIOLIN CONCERTO BY HE ZHANGHAO AND CHEN GANG IN AUTHOR'S TRANSCRIPTIONS: IMAGERY-SEMANTIC AND GENRE TRANSFORMATIONS
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.32782/art/2025.3.15Keywords:
concert, string quartet, transcription, Chinese instrumental music, figurative-semantic transformation, concertity, chamber genre,Abstract
The article examines for the first time the differences between the original musical text of the Concerto for Violin and Orchestra "Liang Tanbo and Zhu Yingtai" by He Zhanghao and Chen Gan and the transcription for violin and string quartet created by Chen Gan, from the standpoint of the variability of the embodiment of musical images in accordance with the semantic roles of different instruments and the laws of different instrumental genres. The figurative semantic and genre transformations of the original musical material are traced, as well as changes in the approach to the interpretation of textural development in the original symphonic and chamber versions of the work. It is established that changes in the textural design of the material also lead to transformations of the figurative content and genre features. In particular, in the lyrical sections of the concerto (introduction, side part or coda), the monologic nature of the statement, the coloristics of the timbres and the pastoral figurative mode of the original version are transformed into dialogicity, graphic lines and a lyrical-psychological content mode in the transcription for the chamber ensemble, and in the main part the epic sublimity of the orchestral original gives way to a dance-scherzo figurative plan in the chamber transcription.The juxtaposition of solo and tutti as the main factor of textural development and the driving force of musical drama in the symphonic score of the Concerto partially gives way to a textural crescendo and the principle of textural contrast between the large sections of the form in the chamber version (the juxtaposition of a transparent, deliberately simplified quartet texture of the exposition and a condensed musical fabric in the development and coda).It is shown that if the original for violin and symphony orchestra is dominated by features of concertity and regularity of symphonic thinking, then the transcription for violin and string quartet acquires typical features of the chamber genre, including detailing of musical material, economy of means of expression, equality of voices, deepening of the psychological principle.Thus, Chen Han's version for chamber ensemble is not just an arrangement of a symphonic score for chamber ensemble, but also a completely independent artistic interpretation of the original composer's idea.
References
Лі Янь Лун. Перетворення китайських національних та європейських тенденцій у Концерті для скрипки з оркестром «Butterfly Lovers» Чень Гана та Цанг Хао. Наукові збірки Львівської національної музичної академії імені М. В. Лисенка. Музикознавчі студії. 2015. Вип. 35. С. 209–221.
Shan-Ken Chien. The Butterfly Lovers’ Violin Concerto by Zhanhao He and Gang Chen. Dissertation for the degree of Doctor of Musical Arts. University of Kansas. Lawrence, 2014. 36 p.
Perez, Herson A. Scholarly Program Notes of He Zhanhao’s (何占豪) and Chen Gang’s (陈钢) Butterfly Lovers Violin Concerto, Johann Sebastian Bach’s Chaconne for Solo Violin and Ludwig van Beethoven’s Violin Sonata op. 12 no. 1. Research Paper for the degree of Master of Music. Southern Illinois University. Carbondale, 2017. 24 p.
Wise, A. A. The Rise Of The Chinese Concerto: A Look Into The Developments Of Chinese Traditional Instrument Concerti With Western Orchestra. Dissertation for the degree of Doctor of Musical Arts. University of South Carolina. Columbia, 2018. 120 p.
Ying Zhang. The Butterfly Lovers’ Violin Concerto (1959). Dissertation for the degree of Doctor of Musical Arts. University of Nevada. Las Vegas, 2021. 51 p.
Suciu M.-M., Drăgulin S. D. Exploring Chinese Cultural Identity in the Liang Zhu Violin Concerto: an Intercultural Perspective on the Adaptation of Traditional Elements in Western Classical Music Language. STUDIA UBB MUSICA, LXVIII. 2023. Special Issue 2. P. 343–360. DOI: https://doi.org/10.24193/subbmusica.2023.spiss2.22
Chen, Yangying Mia. Distinctive Perspectives On Chinese Themes: An Exploration And Comparison On The Avshalomov Violin Concerto And The Butterfly Lovers’ Violin Concerto. Dissertation for the degree of Doctor of Musical Arts. University of Arizona. Tucson, 2024. 64 p.
Chao, Min-Tzu. Interpretation and expressive imagery of the Buterfly Lovers violin concerto on double bass: transcribed by Yung-Chiao Wei. Dissertation for the degree of Doctor of Musical Arts. Louisiana State University and Agricultural and Mechanical College. Baton Rouge, 2011. 138 p.









